News

Maadani found guilty of second-degree murder in 2019 Market killing


Co-accused Islam Rashed was found guilty of the lesser offence of accessory to possession of a loaded prohibited firearm.

Article content

Moadd Maadani has been found guilty of second-degree murder in the July 1, 2019, ByWard Market shooting death of Ryan Kabuya-Ntumba, while his co-accused Islam Rashed was acquitted of accessory to murder after the fact.

Advertisement

Article content

The jury returned with its verdict Thursday after hearing the trial’s closing arguments this week from Assistant Crown Attorneys Mike Boyce and Chantal Lefebvre.

Maadani was represented by Michael Edelson and Rashed was defended by Oliver Abergel, who successfully argued for a “directed verdict” at the conclusion of the four-week trial to dismiss the most serious charge against his client.

Superior Court Justice Julianne Parfett agreed with Abergel’s motion for a directed verdict, tossing accessory charges against Rashed on the grounds that the essential elements of the offence had not been made out in the prosecution’s case.

Rashed was instead found guilty of the lesser offence of accessory to possession of a loaded prohibited firearm.

Advertisement

Article content

“Accessory after the fact to murder is one of the most serious charges in our criminal law, and Mr. Rashed is extremely grateful to the trial judge for exercising her discretion and directing a verdict of acquittal,” Abergel said following the verdict.

A sentencing date for both Maadani and Rashed will be set at a hearing in January.

The jury was shown security video capturing the the chaos that erupted between two groups of friends — the killer’s and the victim’s — following a night of partying on June 30, 2019.

After one group exited a bar near the corner of George and Dalhousie Streets around 3 a.m. on the morning of Canada Day, the two groups were seen arguing before briefly dispersing, then the altercation continued in a nearby alcove.

Advertisement

Article content

The video, shot from above, showed the groups pushing and shoving each other before punches were thrown.

Maadani was seen wearing a satchel, and at one point it appeared as if Rashed attempted to discourage his friend from reaching inside.

Kabuya-Ntumba appeared to motion towards Maadani, who was then seen drawing a handgun from his satchel and pointing it at the victim as several muzzle flashes punctuated the video and Kabuya-Ntumba dropped to the ground.

According to the Crown’s case, Maadani fired five shots during the brawl and he was also shot once in the left leg during the melee.

Kabuya-Ntumba was seen attempting to get up and sprint a few steps before falling again.

There was already a significant police presence downtown, according to testimony from lead investigator Det. Krista Hill, and two police officers administered immediate first aid, but the 21-year-old Kabuya-Ntumba was later pronounced dead in hospital.

Advertisement

Article content

Maadani and Rashed were seen in another surveillance video running north on Dalhousie Street before jumping in a white Chevy Impala.

Three hours and about 200 kilometres later, the two were seen in another surveillance video as they arrived at the Montreal Jewish Hospital’s emergency department around 6 a.m., with Rashed pushing Maadani in a wheelchair.

Maadani had a bullet lodged just above his left knee.

The two gave statements to a pair of Montreal police officers, who both testified later at trial, saying Maadani claimed he’d been shot when someone tried to rob him of an expensive gold necklace.

He was treated in hospital and released.

Ottawa police issued a warrant for Maadani’s arrest and he turned himself in on Aug. 21. Investigators had already obtained a tracking warrant on Rashed’s cellphone and followed his route to Algonquin College on July 18, 2019, when he was promptly arrested.

Advertisement

Article content

Ryan Kabuya-Ntumba was a talented basketball player for St. Patrick’s High School.
Ryan Kabuya-Ntumba was a talented basketball player for St. Patrick’s High School. Photo by Jeff Wilson /Handout

Kabuya-Ntumba was born in Montreal and moved to Ottawa when he was a year old, the middle child of three siblings. He was a gifted athlete who played high school basketball at St. Patrick’s High School, joining the varsity team in his sophomore year and leading the team to numerous championships.

Maadani and Rashed were also former St. Patrick’s students.

Kabuya-Ntumba’s family has created a foundation in his memory devoted to fighting violence linked to firearms.

“He was so loved by many, to the point that his death was experienced like a thunderclap, a heartbreaking event,” his family wrote in a memorial. “That Canada Day will be forever engraved in our memories for life.”

With files from Matthew Lapierre

ahelmer@postmedia.com

Twitter.com/helmera

Advertisement

Comments

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.




Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.